This blog dives into the debate between shaving soap and shaving cream – two mainstays in the shaving department. Discover their differences, plus pros and cons, to help you decide which might become your next favourite.
The traditional charm of shaving soap
Shaving soap is the classic choice for many men, evoking the timeless image of a barber’s shop. It's typically hard and requires a shaving brush to whip up a rich lather. This might sound like extra work, but the results are worth it.
Pros:
- Lather control: For example, by using a high quality shaving brush, you can control the thickness and richness of your lather, tailoring it to your skin's needs.
- Cost-effective: A good quality shaving soap can last significantly longer than shaving creams, offering more shaves per pound and save you money.
- Scent variety: Shaving soaps, especially artisan shaving soaps are available in a huge variety of different scents so you'll be sure to find one you like.
Cons:
- Time-consuming: The process of lathering up with a shaving brush can be more time-consuming than squirting out a cream.
- Learning curve: For beginners, mastering the art of using shaving soap and shaving brushes can be a little tricky when trying to achieve that perfect lather.
The convenience of shaving cream
Shaving cream is loved for its convenience and ease of use. Just a small dollop can quickly produce a luxurious lather, ideal for those hectic mornings.
Pros:
- Ease of use: Perfect for those new to shaving or anyone in a hurry, unlike shave soap cream for shaving can be applied directly by hand or with a brush for a quick, rich lather.
- Variety and availability: There’s a wide range of shaving creams available, including shaving creams for sensitive skin.
- Moisturising properties: Many shaving creams are packed with hydrating ingredients, leaving your skin feeling smooth and less prone to shaving rash.
Cons:
- Cost: You may go through a tube of shaving cream faster than soap, which can add up over time.
- Lather control: While easy to use, some might find the lather from shaving cream less customisable than soap.
How to choose
So, which one is right for you? If you relish the ritual of shaving and enjoy the traditional feel, shaving soap is likely your match. With a your favourite shaving brush in hand, you’ll enjoy the process and the superior control over your lather. On the other hand, if convenience and speed are your top priorities, you’ll appreciate the quick and easy application of shaving cream.
For those concerned about razor bumps, shaving bumps, or shaver’s rash, either product can work well, especially when paired with a safety razor containing a new, sharp double edge razor blade and proper technique.
If you’ve ever wondered, "How do I stop a shaving cut from bleeding?" or "What does a shaving rash look like?", well the answer is that prevention is better than cure. Ensure you’re using quality shaving preparation products that provide the right level of protection and have the right technique. If you do happen to cut yourself, the quickest solution is to apply a styptic pencil or alum block, which helps to seal the cut and stop the bleeding instantly. Alternatively, pressing a clean, damp tissue or cloth to the area can also help. If you suspect you have a shaving rash, it typically appears as red, irritated patches or tiny bumps on the skin, often accompanied by itching or a burning sensation.
Whether you’re a fan of the traditional shaving soap & meditative process of brush shaving, or prefer the modern convenience of shaving cream, there’s no wrong choice. Both have their unique advantages and can cater to different lifestyles and preferences.
Here's a few products we recommend
- Mitchell's Wool Fat Shaving Soap: A popular shaving soap with a cult following that is known for its excellent post-shave feel.
- Castle Forbes Lime Shaving Cream: A luxury shaving cream beautifully fragranced only with the purest essential oil. Free from parabens, colours and added fragrance. A little bit goes a long way with this shaving cream.
- Phoenix & Beau Spitfire Shaving Soap: A UK made, small batch artisan shaving soap with a bold, warming leather and rich tobacco scent.
- Taylor of Old Bond Street Jermyn Street Shaving Cream: With its beautiful masculine fragrance this shaving cream also contains Aloe Vera leaf juice making it an excellent choice if you have sensitive skin.
- Simpsons Trafalgar T3 Synthetic Shaving Brush: Whether you prefer shaving soap or shaving cream we still recommend that both are applied using a shaving brush to gently exfoliate your skin and aid razor glide. The Simpson Trafalgar T3 is a great performing shaving brush capable of whipping up a rich, dense lather from either soap or cream and because its synthetic it's vegan friendly too.
Explore our range at Blades & Whiskers to find your perfect fit and elevate your shaving routine to a whole new level of smoothness.